Appeal from
Abdulrahman Abubakar and Anor. v. Senator Attai Aidoko Usman and 3 others
AI analysis- Court:
- Court of Appeal, Abuja Division
- Suit number:
- CA/A/EPT/609/2015
- Judgment date:
- 2 December 2015
Why it was identified: The primary judgment arose from an application concerning the Court of Appeal judgment in this election petition appeal, which nullified the appellant’s election and ordered a fresh election.
Appeal from
Abdulrahman Abubakar and Anor. v. Senator Attai Aidoko Usman and 3 others
AI analysis- Court:
- Court of Appeal, Abuja Division
- Suit number:
- CA/A/36A/M/2016
- Judgment date:
- 11 February 2016
Why it was identified: The Supreme Court appeal challenged the Court of Appeal ruling striking out the appellants’ motion seeking correction or alteration of the Court of Appeal’s final election judgment.
Related subject matter
Dangana v. Usman
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2012) All FWLR (Pt. 627) 612; (2012) LPELR-25012 (SC); (2013) 6 NWLR (Pt. 1349) 50
Why it was identified: The primary judgment relies extensively on Dangana v. Usman for the proposition that section 246(3) makes the Court of Appeal final in National Assembly election appeals.
Related subject matter
Onuaguluchi v. Ndu & Ors.
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2001) FWLR (Pt. 45) 740; (2001) 7 NWLR (Pt. 712) 309
Why it was identified: The decision is quoted and relied upon for the rule that procedural or jurisdictional errors in National Assembly election appeals cannot be corrected by the Supreme Court after the Court of Appeal’s final decision.
Related subject matter
Opara v. Amadi
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2013) All FWLR (Pt. 709) 1019; (2013) 6-7 SC (Pt. 2) 49
Why it was identified: It is identified among the Supreme Court authorities concerning the finality of Court of Appeal decisions in election petition appeals.
Related subject matter
Madumere v. Okwara
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2013) 12 NWLR (Pt. 1368) 303; (2013) LPELR-20752 (SC); (2014) All FWLR (Pt. 720) 1247
Why it was identified: The primary judgment quotes Madumere v. Okwara as authority that section 246(3) bars further appeals from the Court of Appeal in National and State Houses of Assembly election petitions.
Related subject matter
Okadigbo v. Emeka
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2012) All FWLR (Pt. 623) 1869; (2012) NSCQR (Pt. 49) 1026; (2012) LPELR-7839 (SC)
Why it was identified: It is relied upon for the proposition that the Court of Appeal is the final court in appeals arising from National and State Houses of Assembly election petitions.
Related subject matter
Emordi v. Igbeke
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2011) All FWLR (Pt. 580) 1262; (2011) 4 SC (Pt. 11) 107; (2011) 9 NWLR (Pt. 1251) 24
Why it was identified: The primary judgment lists and relies on this decision as part of the consistent Supreme Court authorities on constitutional finality under section 246(3).
Related subject matter
Salik v. Idris
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2014) 15 NWLR (Pt. 1439) 36; (2015) All FWLR (Pt. 790) 1307
Why it was identified: It is cited among the authorities establishing that no further Supreme Court appeal lies from the relevant Court of Appeal election decision.
Related subject matter
Jegede v. Akande
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2014) 16 NWLR (Pt. 1432) 43
Why it was identified: The judgment identifies Jegede v. Akande among the decisions confirming the constitutional finality of the Court of Appeal in election petition appeals.
Related subject matter
Dingyadi v. I.N.E.C. (No. 1)
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2010) All FWLR (Pt. 550) 1204; (2010) 18 NWLR (Pt. 1224) 1
Why it was identified: It is cited as authority for the interpretation that section 246(3) prevents further appeals to the Supreme Court from the Court of Appeal in election matters.
Related subject matter
Ugwa v. Lekwauwa
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2010) 19 NWLR (Pt. 1226) 26; (2011) All FWLR (Pt. 564) 1
Why it was identified: The primary judgment cites Ugwa v. Lekwauwa in support of the finality rule under section 246(3).
Related subject matter
Sha’Aban v. Sambo
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2010) 19 NWLR (Pt. 2226) 353
Why it was identified: It is cited as part of the line of decisions holding that Court of Appeal decisions in National and State Houses of Assembly election appeals are final.
Related subject matter
Awuse v. Odili
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2004) All FWLR (Pt. 212) 1664; (2003) 18 NWLR (Pt. 851) 116
Why it was identified: The primary judgment quotes Awuse v. Odili for the rule that the Court of Appeal is the final court in appeals arising from election petitions under section 246(3).
Related subject matter
Esewe v. N. T. Gbe
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1888) 5 NWLR (Pt. 93) 134
Why it was identified: It is cited in the discussion of the constitutional finality of Court of Appeal decisions in election petition appeals.
Related subject matter
Rt Hon Abdullahi Bello and anor. v. Hon Yusuf Ahmed Tijani Damisa and Ors.
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Suit number:
- SC.168/2016
- Judgment date:
- 9 December 2016
Why it was identified: The primary judgment expressly refers to this recent Supreme Court decision as having reaffirmed that section 246(3) deprives the Supreme Court of jurisdiction over such appeals.
Related subject matter
Okacha Samuel Osi v. Accord and Ors.
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Suit number:
- SC.187/2016
- Judgment date:
- 9 December 2016
Why it was identified: It is expressly identified as another Supreme Court decision delivered on the same day maintaining the same position on section 246(3).
Related subject matter
Hon Barambu Umaru and Anor v. PDP and Ors.
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Suit number:
- SC.120/2016
- Judgment date:
- 9 December 2016
Why it was identified: It is expressly identified as another decision reaffirming the finality of the Court of Appeal in National and State Houses of Assembly election appeals.
Related subject matter
PDP v. CPC
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2011) 17 NWLR (Pt. 1277) 485
Why it was identified: The Court of Appeal ruling, discussed in the primary judgment, relied on PDP v. CPC concerning the statutory time limit for consequential orders in election matters.
Related subject matter
Njoku v. Dikibo
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1998) 1 NWLR (Pt. 534) 496
Why it was identified: It is cited by Bage JSC in relation to estoppel per rem judicatum and the public policy that litigation must have an end.
Related subject matter
Aro v. Fabolude
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1983) 2 SC 75; (1983) 1 SCNLR 58; (1983) 1 All NLR 67
Why it was identified: It is cited in the discussion of estoppel per rem judicatum and finality of litigation.
Related subject matter
Cardoso & Ors. v. Mrs. Williams
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1982) 7 SC 27
Why it was identified: It is cited as an authority concerning estoppel per rem judicatum and the need for finality in litigation.
Related subject matter
Suleiman v. Commissioner of Police, Plateau State
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2008) All FWLR (Pt. 425) 1627; (2008) 8 NWLR (Pt. 1089) 298
Why it was identified: It is cited for the principle that sympathy or empathy cannot override the law.
Related subject matter
Udosen v. State
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2007) All FWLR (Pt. 356) 669; (2007) 4 NWLR (Pt. 1023) 125
Why it was identified: It is cited with other authorities for the irrelevance of sympathy to the application of law.
Related subject matter
Ezeugo v. Ohanyere
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1978) 6-7 SC 171; (1978) 11 NSCC 449
Why it was identified: It is cited for the proposition that sympathy does not determine legal outcomes.
Related subject matter
Oniah v. Onyia
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1989) 1 NWLR (Pt. 99) 514; (1989) 2 SCNJ 120
Why it was identified: It is cited among the authorities stating that sympathy is irrelevant to the law.
Related subject matter
Omole and Sons Ltd v. Adeyemo
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1994) 4 NWLR (Pt. 336) 48
Why it was identified: It is cited for the principle that legal decisions cannot be based on sympathy or empathy.
Related subject matter
Mark v. Eke
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2004) All FWLR (Pt. 200) 1455; (2004) 5 NWLR (Pt. 865) 54
Why it was identified: The appellants cited Mark v. Eke in arguing that the courts could exercise jurisdiction to correct or set aside an allegedly void decision.
Related subject matter
Ukiri v. United Bank for Africa Plc
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2016) All FWLR (Pt. 854) 1954; (2016) 3 NWLR (Pt. 1500) 440
Why it was identified: The appellants cited Ukiri v. United Bank for Africa Plc in support of their jurisdictional argument concerning the ability to revisit a decision alleged to be void.
Related subject matter
Eco consult Ltd. v. Pancho Villa Limited
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1999) 1 NWLR (Pt. 588) 507
Why it was identified: It is cited in the quoted discussion of the finality of Court of Appeal decisions in election petition appeals.
Related subject matter
Banire v. Balogun
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1986) 4 NWLR (Pt. 38) 746
Why it was identified: It appears in the judgment’s list of Nigerian cases referred to, in the context of authorities concerning finality and estoppel.
Related subject matter
Ishola v. Ajiboye
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1998) 1 NWLR (Pt. 532) 1
Why it was identified: It is cited by Bage JSC in connection with estoppel per rem judicatum and finality of litigation.
Same transaction
Air Marshal Isaac M. Alfa, CFR v. PDP & Ors.
AI analysis- Court:
- Federal High Court
- Suit number:
- FHC/ABJ/CS/1073/2014
- Judgment date:
- 18 April 2016
Why it was identified: The judgment was cited by the appellants, and the primary judgment records that the Court of Appeal subsequently set aside it in a related dispute concerning the same senatorial seat.
Same transaction
Senator Atai Aidoko v. Air Marshall Isaac Alfa and Ors.
AI analysis- Court:
- Court of Appeal, Abuja Division
- Suit number:
- CA/A/260/2016
- Judgment date:
- 14 December 2016
Why it was identified: The primary judgment expressly states that this Court of Appeal decision set aside the Federal High Court judgment in the related dispute concerning the Kogi East senatorial seat.