Appeal from
High Court of Justice, Federal Capital Territory, Abuja decision in Alhaji Abubakar Zaki & Ors. v. Alhaji Jibo Magayaki & Ors.
AI analysis- Court:
- High Court of Justice, Federal Capital Territory, Abuja
- Judgment date:
- 15 October 1998
Why it was identified: The primary judgment expressly states that the appeal was from the judgment of Kusherki J. of the High Court of Justice, Abuja, delivered on 15 October 1998, which awarded damages to the plaintiffs; the Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, set aside that decision, and dismissed the claim.
- Citation:
- (1992) 3 NWLR (Pt. 230) 426 at 442-443
Why it was identified: The primary judgment relies on Karibo vs. Grend for the principle that a trial judge must review, appraise and weigh the evidence of both parties before deciding which case is more probable.
- Citation:
- (1990) 4 NWLR (Pt. 147) 746 at 775
Why it was identified: The primary judgment cites Olawuyi vs. Adeyemi for the requirement that the quality of evidence must be evaluated to determine whether a plaintiff has proved the case on the balance of probabilities.
Other
Atoyebi vs. The Governor of Oyo State
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1994) 9 Kings Law Report (Pt. 21) 1 at 22
Why it was identified: The primary judgment cites Atoyebi for the proposition that merely summarising or restating evidence without judicial analysis and reasons for accepting or rejecting it is not proper evaluation of evidence.
- Citation:
- (1999) 4 NWLR (Pt. 599) 34
Why it was identified: The primary judgment relies on INEC vs. Korshi for the rule that an appellate court should not interfere with findings reasonably supported by properly evaluated evidence.
Other
Fatoyinbo vs. Williams
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1956) FSC 87
Why it was identified: The primary judgment cites Fatoyinbo vs. Williams in explaining that findings based on witness credibility and demeanour are principally for the trial court and are ordinarily not disturbed on appeal.
- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1984) 4 S.C. 84; (2000) FWLR (Pt. 27) 2094
Why it was identified: The primary judgment refers to Egba vs. Ogodo alongside Fatoyinbo vs. Williams on the limited appellate interference with credibility-based findings of fact.
- Citation:
- (1974) 1 All NLR 35
Why it was identified: The primary judgment cites Fashanu vs. Adeko for the principle that an appellate court may re-evaluate evidence where the relevant finding depends on the printed record and application of law rather than witness credibility.
- Citation:
- (1992) 5 NWLR (Pt. 242) 410 at 427
Why it was identified: The primary judgment cites Adegoke vs. Adibi for the competence of the Court of Appeal to evaluate evidence by way of rehearing where the trial court failed to evaluate it properly.
Other
Lion Buildings vs. M. M. Shodipe
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1976) 12 S.C. 135
Why it was identified: The primary judgment refers to Lion Buildings vs. M. M. Shodipe as authority supporting the Court of Appeal’s duty to undertake evaluation of evidence where necessary despite its appellate status.
- Citation:
- (1881-1911) 1 NLR 35
Why it was identified: The primary judgment cites Macauley vs. Tukuru in support of appellate rehearing and re-evaluation of evidence following an inadequately evaluated trial record.
Other
Benmax vs. Austin Motor Co. Ltd.
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1955) AC 370
Why it was identified: The primary judgment cites Benmax vs. Austin Motor Co. Ltd. as comparative authority concerning appellate evaluation of evidence and findings of fact.
- Court:
- Court of Appeal, Port Harcourt Division
- Citation:
- (1995) 7 NWLR (Pt. 408) 423 at 444-445
Why it was identified: The primary judgment relies on Okoromaka vs. Odiri for the settled appellate approach to findings of fact, including interference where findings are perverse, legally unsound, or omit relevant facts.
- Citation:
- (1991) 5 NWLR (Pt. 191) 365 at 381-383
Why it was identified: The primary judgment refers to Udo vs. Okupa concerning the difficulty and necessity of careful evaluation of evidence by a trial judge.
- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2001) 16 NWLR (Pt. 738) 58 at 77
Why it was identified: The primary judgment states that the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal against the Court of Appeal decision in Nteogwuile vs. Otuo and refers to it for guidelines on appellate interference with trial findings.
- Citation:
- (1997) 4 S.C. 9
Why it was identified: The primary judgment applies Mogaji vs. Odofin’s imaginary-scale approach to weighing evidence and determining whether the plaintiffs discharged the civil burden of proof.
Other
Nimantekes Associates Ltd. vs. Marco Construction Co. Ltd.
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1991) 2 NWLR (Pt. 174) 441 at 430
Why it was identified: The primary judgment cites Nimantekes Associates Ltd. vs. Marco Construction Co. Ltd. on the principle that a party asserting a fact bears the burden of proving it.
Other
Achora vs. Attorney General, Bendel State
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1990) 7 NWLR (Pt. 160) 92 at 98
Why it was identified: The primary judgment relies on Achora to distinguish inadmissible hearsay evidence offered to prove the truth of a statement from admissible evidence offered merely to prove that the statement was made.
Other
Qua Steel Products Ltd. & Anor. vs. Bassey
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1992) 5 NWLR (Pt. 239) 67 at 75-76
Why it was identified: The primary judgment cites Qua Steel Products Ltd. vs. Bassey in addressing the liability of an agent of a disclosed principal and the effect of contractual indemnity provisions on a non-party.
Other
Edewor vs. Ewegba & Ors.
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1987) S.C. 49 at 99; (1987) 2 S.C. 49 at 99
Why it was identified: The primary judgment relies on Edewor vs. Ewegba for the rule that a court should not make a case for the parties or decide an issue raised suo motu without inviting submissions from the parties.