- Citation:
- (2001) FWLR (Pt. 41) 1872
Why it was identified: Cited for the rule that an objection to the voluntariness of a confessional statement should be raised when the statement is tendered, not for the first time during the defence.
Other
Egboghonome v. State
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1993) 9 SCNJ 1
Why it was identified: Relied on as the Supreme Court authority clarifying that the inconsistency rule applies to a witness’s statement and testimony, and does not generally apply to an accused person’s previous confession and evidence in court.
- Citation:
- (1964) All NLR 21
Why it was identified: Identified as the earlier authority establishing that the inconsistency rule does not apply to an accused person’s previous confession and subsequent evidence in court.
- Citation:
- (2008) 11 NWLR (Pt. 1099) 467; (2009) All FWLR (Pt. 494) 1461
Why it was identified: The appellant relied on this case for the contrary formulation of the inconsistency rule; the Court of Appeal expressly rejected that approach as inconsistent with the prevailing Nigerian law.
Other
Femi Oladotun v. State
AI analysis- Court:
- Court of Appeal, Ilorin Division
- Suit number:
- CA/IL/C.46/2009
- Citation:
- Unreported
- Judgment date:
- 11 December 2009
Why it was identified: The judgment cites this later decision of the same division, delivered by Nweze JCA, as rejecting reliance on the inconsistency rule in Ojo v. FRN and reaffirming Udo and Egboghonome.
- Citation:
- (2001) 2 NWLR (Pt. 746) 793; (2002) FWLR (Pt. 91) 1605
Why it was identified: Cited for the proposition that statements should, where practicable, be recorded in the language in which they were made, but failure to do so does not automatically render them inadmissible.
Other
Abayomi Oyekan v. State
AI analysis
Why it was identified: The judgment quotes this Supreme Court authority on recording an accused person’s statement in the language used and the non-fatal effect of recording it in another language where accuracy is ensured.
- Citation:
- (1971) 1 All NLR 151
Why it was identified: Cited with Edet v. State and R. v. Omokaro for the principle that a free, voluntary, direct and properly proved confession may sustain a conviction.
- Citation:
- (1965) NMLR 119
Why it was identified: Cited as authority that a direct, positive, voluntary and properly proved confessional statement can ground a conviction.
- Citation:
- (1941) 7 WACA 146
Why it was identified: Cited as authority for conviction founded on a free and voluntary confession that is direct, positive and properly proved.
- Citation:
- (1992) 2 NWLR (Pt. 223) 257
Why it was identified: Relied on for the distinction between hearsay evidence offered to prove the truth of a statement and admissible evidence offered merely to prove that the statement was made or heard.
- Citation:
- (2001) 15 NWLR (Pt. 735) 47
Why it was identified: Cited for the principle that evidence of a statement is not hearsay when tendered to establish the fact that the statement was made rather than the truth of its contents.
- Citation:
- (1992) 4 NWLR (Pt. 233) 57
Why it was identified: Cited as an example of admissible direct evidence where witnesses testified to what they heard the deceased say during the incident.
- Citation:
- (1999) 8 NWLR (Pt. 615) 374
Why it was identified: Cited for the admissibility of testimony about what a witness personally heard during an incident, distinguishing such evidence from hearsay.
Other
Mohammed v. Kano N.A.
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1968) 1 All NLR 411
Why it was identified: Referred to for the proposition that fair hearing necessarily includes a fair trial and is assessed from the impression of a reasonable person observing whether justice was done.
- Citation:
- (2001) 15 NWLR (Pt. 737) 745
Why it was identified: Cited as a post-Egboghonome authority adopting the position that the inconsistency rule does not apply to an accused person’s previous confession and trial evidence.
- Citation:
- (2004) 18 NWLR (Pt. 905) 292
Why it was identified: Listed and relied on as a subsequent authority reverting to the Udo position concerning the inapplicability of the inconsistency rule to an accused person’s confession and testimony.
Other
Dibie and Ors v. State
AI analysis- Citation:
- (2007) All FWLR (Pt. 363) 83
Why it was identified: Cited among the post-Egboghonome decisions reaffirming that an accused person’s previous confession is not rendered unusable by inconsistency with evidence given in court.
- Citation:
- (2009) 32 WRN 47
Why it was identified: Cited as a subsequent authority supporting the restricted application of the inconsistency rule to ordinary witness statements and testimony.
- Citation:
- (2009) 29 WRN 86
Why it was identified: Relied on as a recent authority that the inconsistency rule does not apply to a previous confession of an accused person and the accused’s evidence in court.
- Citation:
- (2009) All FWLR (Pt. 454) 1450
Why it was identified: Cited as a post-Egboghonome authority confirming the inapplicability of the inconsistency rule to previous confessions and subsequent testimony of an accused person.
- Citation:
- (1961) 1 SCNLR 53; (1961) All NLR 25
Why it was identified: Identified as the first Nigerian case adopting the inconsistency rule, historically applying it to ordinary prosecution witnesses rather than accused persons.
- Citation:
- (1960) 1 WLR 1169
Why it was identified: Identified as the English authority in which Lord Parker CJ expounded the inconsistency rule later adopted in Queen v. Ukpong.
- Citation:
- (1985) 1 NWLR (Pt. 3) 470
Why it was identified: Discussed as the decision that first extended the inconsistency rule to an accused person’s statement and evidence, a position later rejected or limited by subsequent Supreme Court decisions.
- Citation:
- (1987) 3 NWLR (Pt. 61) 538
Why it was identified: Cited for the criminal-law standard that the prosecution must prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt, without requiring proof beyond every conceivable shadow of doubt.
- Citation:
- (1987) 3 SC 1
Why it was identified: Relied on for the meaning of proof beyond reasonable doubt in a criminal trial.
- Citation:
- (1992) 7 NWLR (Pt. 256) 658
Why it was identified: Cited for the prosecution’s continuing burden to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt and the accused’s entitlement to the benefit of reasonable doubt.
- Citation:
- (2008) 12 NWLR (Pt. 1101) 518
Why it was identified: Cited by the appellant on whether a co-accused’s confessional statement should remain on the record when that co-accused did not complete trial.
- Citation:
- (1994) 14 NWLR (Pt. 637) 1
Why it was identified: Cited for the statutory principle that a confession is relevant against its maker, in the context of the co-accused’s statement admitted as exhibit P4.