Appeal from
Godwin Igabele v. The State
AI analysis- Court:
- High Court of Justice, Enugu
- Judgment date:
- 9 May 1991
Why it was identified: The primary judgment is an appeal against the High Court of Justice, Enugu judgment of 9 May 1991 convicting the appellant of murder and imposing the death sentence; the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal and affirmed that decision.
- Citation:
- (1953) 20 NLR 62
Why it was identified: Cited for the meaning and effect of a no case submission.
- Citation:
- (1999) 2 NWLR (Pt. 590) 246
Why it was identified: Cited for the fundamental ingredients the prosecution must prove in a murder charge.
- Citation:
- (1996) 5 NWLR (Pt. 448) 270
Why it was identified: Cited on the ingredients of murder and the prosecution’s burden of proof.
- Citation:
- (1985) 3 NWLR (Pt. 12) 236
Why it was identified: Cited for the requirements for proving murder and the rule that suspicion cannot ground a conviction.
- Citation:
- (2002) 4 SCNJ 282
Why it was identified: Cited as a Supreme Court restatement of the ingredients of murder.
- Citation:
- (1972) 2 ECSLR 429
Why it was identified: Cited for the requirement of an unbroken nexus between the accused’s act and the death in unlawful homicide cases.
Other
Peter Igho v. The State
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1978) 3 SC 87
Why it was identified: Expressly identified by the lead judgment as factually similar because the deceased was last seen with the appellant and guilt was inferred from circumstantial evidence.
- Citation:
- (1911) CAR 225
Why it was identified: Cited in the discussion of an accused’s failure to explain circumstances calling for explanation.
- Citation:
- (2001) FWLR (Pt. 66) 682; (2001) 14 NWLR (Pt. 734) 666
Why it was identified: Cited on inferring cause of death from circumstances and on the evidential burden following establishment of a prima facie case.
Other
Aiguoreghian v. State
AI analysis- Citation:
- (2004) All FWLR (Pt. 195) 716; (2004) 3 NWLR (Pt. 860) 367
Why it was identified: Cited for circumstances in which the cause of death may be inferred from circumstantial evidence.
Other
Edet Obosi v. The State
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1965) NMLR 119
Why it was identified: Cited for compelling circumstantial evidence leaving no room for acquittal.
Other
Elijah Ukoh v. The State
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1971) NMLR 140
Why it was identified: Cited in support of drawing an irresistible inference of guilt from circumstantial evidence.
- Citation:
- (1996) 2 NWLR (Pt. 428) 1; (1996) 2 SCNJ 42
Why it was identified: Cited on the sufficiency of compelling circumstantial evidence.
- Citation:
- (1980) 8-11 SC 76
Why it was identified: Cited in support of the conclusion that the circumstantial evidence pointed exclusively to the appellant.
- Citation:
- (1981) 5 SC 5
Why it was identified: Cited alongside Peba v. State on cogent and unequivocal circumstantial evidence.
- Citation:
- (1976) 11 SC 133
Why it was identified: Cited for the principles governing conviction on circumstantial evidence.
- Citation:
- (1980) 1-2 SC 116; (1980) 1-2 SCNJ 127
Why it was identified: Cited on the careful examination and sufficiency of circumstantial evidence.
- Citation:
- (1980) 1 NCR 4
Why it was identified: Cited for the standard applicable to circumstantial evidence.
- Citation:
- (1999) 2 NWLR (Pt. 589) 87
Why it was identified: Cited on circumstantial evidence and the meaning of proof beyond reasonable doubt.
- Citation:
- (1952) AC 480
Why it was identified: Cited for the requirement that circumstantial evidence exclude co-existing circumstances weakening the inference of guilt.
Other
Queen v. Ororosokode
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1960) SCNLR 501; 5 FSC 208
Why it was identified: Cited on the standard for drawing guilt from circumstantial evidence.
Other
The State v. Omada Edobor & Ors.
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1975) 9-11 SC 69
Why it was identified: Cited for drawing inferences from circumstantial evidence and proving death even where the body or trace of the body is absent.
- Citation:
- (1976) 11 SC 39
Why it was identified: Cited on when courts should draw presumptions or inferences from cogent circumstantial evidence.
- Citation:
- (1976) 1 SC 125
Why it was identified: Cited alongside Esai v. State on drawing an inference where no rational alternative exists.
- Citation:
- (1995) 7 NWLR (Pt. 406) 204
Why it was identified: Cited for the meaning of circumstantial evidence.
- Citation:
- (2000) FWLR (Pt. 1) 138; (2000) 1 SCNJ 50
Why it was identified: Cited for the meaning of a prima facie case.
- Citation:
- (1964) 1 All NLR 423
Why it was identified: Cited on matters peculiarly within the accused’s knowledge and the evidential burden after a prima facie case is established.
- Citation:
- (1980) 2 PLR 50
Why it was identified: Cited on the consequence of an accused person’s election not to give evidence in explanation of incriminating circumstances.
Other
Ohuka v. State (No. 2)
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1988) 4 NWLR (Pt. 86) 36
Why it was identified: Cited on drawing inferences from an accused person’s silence.
- Citation:
- (1983) 1 SCNLR 120
Why it was identified: Cited for the effect of admitting exhibits without objection.
- Citation:
- (1977) 11 NSCC 166
Why it was identified: Cited for the proposition that circumstantial evidence may alone establish guilt beyond reasonable doubt where facts call for an explanation that is not given.
- Citation:
- (1989) 5 NWLR (Pt. 120) 238
Why it was identified: Cited in relation to the evidential inference arising from the appellant’s account of the deceased’s death.
- Citation:
- (1990) 3 NWLR (Pt. 139) 505
Why it was identified: Cited alongside Ibina v. The State on the evidential significance of the rejected account of death.
- Citation:
- (1985) 1 SC 406
Why it was identified: Cited on the effects of crime on the accused, victim, and society, in the context of unlawful homicide.
Other
Woolmington v. D.P.P.
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1935) AC 462
Why it was identified: Cited for the principle that the prosecution bears the burden of proving guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
Other
Yongo & Anor. v. C.O.P.
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1992) 8 NWLR (Pt. 257) 36; (1992) 9 SCNJ 113
Why it was identified: Cited on proof beyond reasonable doubt.
- Citation:
- (1974) 9 SC 1
Why it was identified: Cited on the criminal standard of proof.
- Citation:
- (1993) 2 NWLR (Pt. 273) 1
Why it was identified: Cited in explaining that proof beyond reasonable doubt is not proof beyond every conceivable doubt.
Other
Miller v. Minister of Pensions
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1947) 3 All ER 373
Why it was identified: Cited for the meaning and limits of proof beyond reasonable doubt.
- Citation:
- (1955) 1 QB 388
Why it was identified: Cited for proving death by circumstantial evidence even where no body or trace of a body is found.