Appeal from
Samchase Nigeria Ltd v. Alhaji Saka Gidado
AI analysis- Court:
- Ekiti State High Court, Ado-Ekiti
- Suit number:
- HAD/27/2007
- Judgment date:
- 28 February 2013
Why it was identified: The Court of Appeal identified the appeal as arising from the judgment of J. E. Adeyeye J. of the Ekiti State High Court in suit HAD/27/2007, delivered on 28 February 2013. The appellate court set aside the order concerning redirection of Awedele Stream and affirmed the other orders.
Other
Iweka v. SCOA Nig. Ltd
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2000) 7 NWLR (Pt. 664) 325
Why it was identified: The judgment extensively examined conflicting lead and concurring opinions in Iweka on whether an interlocutory complaint could be joined to an appeal against a final judgment without extension of time.
- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2004) All FWLR (Pt. 220) 1243; (2004) 6–7 SC 136; (2004) 13 NWLR (Pt. 890) 128
Why it was identified: The Court of Appeal relied on Nwana for the principle that a concurring judgment must agree with the lead judgment and cannot depart from it on a material issue.
- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1998) 8 NWLR (Pt. 561) 283
Why it was identified: The judgment cited Akpoku for the rule that the lead judgment constitutes the judgment of the appellate court where a concurring opinion is inconsistent with it.
Other
Ondo State Independent Electoral Commission v. A. C. & Ors
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2010) 12 SC 108
Why it was identified: The Court of Appeal referred to Ondo State Independent Electoral Commission in discussing the binding effect of the majority view where the lead and concurring judgments differ.
- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1997) 10 NWLR (Pt. 524) 179
Why it was identified: Ogigie was relied upon for the procedure requiring leave or extension of time to combine an out-of-time interlocutory appeal with an appeal against a final judgment.
- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2002) 5 SC (Pt. 11) 124; (2002) FWLR (Pt. 110) 1951
Why it was identified: The judgment relied on Ndulue as the later Supreme Court authority holding that an out-of-time interlocutory issue requiring leave cannot be raised in the appeal without the necessary extension or leave.
Other
Obiuweubi v. C. B. N.
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2011) NWLR (Pt. 1247) 465
Why it was identified: The judgment cited Obiuweubi for the proposition that, where Supreme Court decisions conflict, the later decision is to be followed.
Other
Osakwe v. F.C.E. (Tech.) Asaba
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2010) All FWLR (Pt. 522) 1661
Why it was identified: Osakwe was cited with Obiuweubi on the rule that the latest applicable Supreme Court decision binds the Court of Appeal where decisions conflict.
- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1974) 3 SC 67
Why it was identified: The Court of Appeal relied on Amakor for the principle that trespass is actionable by a person in exclusive possession, even without proof of ownership, unless the defendant establishes a better title or right to possession.
- Citation:
- (1978) 11 NSCC 423
Why it was identified: Ikpang was cited on the rule that a claim for trespass is rooted in possession and may be maintained by a person in possession against a party unable to show a better right.
- Citation:
- (1990) 5 NWLR (Pt. 148) 24
Why it was identified: The judgment cited Olaloye as authority on trespass to land and the relevance of exclusive possession rather than proof of title alone.
- Citation:
- (1990) 7 SC 46
Why it was identified: Ajero was cited with Amakor and Ikpang concerning the basis of an action for trespass and the right of a possessor to sue.
Other
Niko Engineering Ltd v. Akinsina
AI analysis- Citation:
- (2005) All FWLR (Pt. 284) 292
Why it was identified: The judgment relied on Niko Engineering for the meaning of volenti non fit injuria and the requirement that the defence be properly pleaded and proved.
Why it was identified: Ajibade was relied on for the doctrine that a person who lawfully enters land but subsequently abuses the authority granted may become a trespasser ab initio.
Other
Redland Bricks Ltd. v. Morris
AI analysis- Court:
- House of Lords
- Citation:
- (1970) A.C. 652
Why it was identified: The Court of Appeal adopted the principles in Redland Bricks governing the discretionary grant of a mandatory injunction, including adequacy of damages, proportionality, and clarity of the required act.
- Citation:
- (1973) 3 ECSLR (Pt. 1) 136
Why it was identified: Nwose was cited for the requirement that the subject of an injunction be sufficiently identifiable to permit enforcement and determination of any alleged breach.
- Citation:
- (2003) 16 NWLR (Pt. 817) 496
Why it was identified: The judgment relied on Kankia in applying the requirement that land or the subject of injunctive relief be clearly identifiable.
- Citation:
- (1999) 2 NWLR (Pt. 591) 437
Why it was identified: Ichu was cited for the importance of an accurate description of the subject matter of an injunction, particularly if breach proceedings arise.
- Citation:
- (2004) All FWLR (Pt. 200) 1484; (2004) 3 NWLR (Pt. 861) 610
Why it was identified: Ewo was relied on for the evidential principle that the burden lies on the party asserting a positive fact, including alleged diversion of a stream.
- Citation:
- (2008) All FWLR (Pt. 443) 1302
Why it was identified: Agbaje was cited alongside Ewo on the burden of proving an asserted fact in civil proceedings.
- Citation:
- (1985) 1 NWLR (Pt. 2) 360
Why it was identified: The judgment relied on Atolagbe for the meaning of a perverse decision and the appellate power to intervene where a trial court overlooks relevant evidence.
Other
Iyere v. Bendel Feeds and Flour Mills Ltd
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2009) All FWLR (Pt. 453) 1217
Why it was identified: Iyere was applied on agency, liability for torts committed by agents, joint and several liability of joint tortfeasors, and the distinction between an agent and an independent contractor.
Other
Ifeanyi Chukwu (Osondu) Ltd v. Soleh Boneh Ltd
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2000) 5 NWLR (Pt. 656) 322
Why it was identified: The judgment cited Ifeanyi Chukwu on the effect of non-joinder of a joint tortfeasor and held that such non-joinder does not defeat a tort claim.