Appeal from
Sokoto State Government v. Kamdex Nig. Ltd
AI analysis- Court:
- Court of Appeal, Lagos Division
- Suit number:
- CA/L/108/2001; CA/L/109/2001; CA/L/110/2001
- Judgment date:
- 22 January 2004
Why it was identified: The Supreme Court appeal arose from the consolidated Court of Appeal appeals, which were heard by Ogebe, Aderemi and Chukwuma-Eneh JJCA but decided by a differently constituted panel including Galadima JCA.
Other
Ubwa v. Tiv Traditional Council & Others
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2004) All FWLR (Pt. 214) 16; (2004) 11 NWLR (Pt. 884) 427
Why it was identified: The lead judgment expressly states that Ubwa involved essentially similar Court of Appeal proceedings and treated the differently constituted panel and resulting judgment as a nullity.
Other
Shuaibu v. Nigerian-Arab Bank Ltd
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1998) 5 NWLR (Pt. 551) 582
Why it was identified: The judgment expressly compares Shuaibu with Ubwa and distinguishes it on the basis that the same panel heard and delivered judgment in Shuaibu.
Other
Madukolu v. Nkemdilim
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1962) 2 SCNLR 34; (1962) All NLR 587
Why it was identified: The Supreme Court repeatedly relies on Madukolu for the principles that competence is essential to jurisdiction and that defects in competence render proceedings a nullity.
- Citation:
- (2002) FWLR (Pt. 127) 1024; (2002) 16 NWLR (Pt. 792) 175
Why it was identified: The judgment cites Orugbo in support of the proposition that participation by a Justice who did not hear the appeal breaches fair-hearing principles.
Other
Adeigbe & Anor. v. Kusimo & Ors.
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1965) 1 All NLR (reprint) 260
Why it was identified: Adeigbe is expressly cited for the rule that proceedings are null where a court is differently constituted during the hearing or a member did not hear the whole evidence.
Other
Tawiah III v. Ewudzi
AI analysis- Court:
- West Africa Court of Appeal
- Citation:
- (1936) 3 WACA 52
Why it was identified: The judgment identifies Tawiah III v. Ewudzi as an authority that failure of all adjudicators to hear the evidence renders the trial and subsequent proceedings a nullity.
- Citation:
- (1988) 3 NWLR (Pt. 85) 696
Why it was identified: Akoh is expressly relied upon for the proposition that proceedings extend through delivery of the final judgment.
- Citation:
- (1986) 1 NWLR (Pt. 17) 437
Why it was identified: Maiwa is cited among the authorities defining competence of a court and the fatal effect of a competence defect.
- Citation:
- (1986) 5 NWLR (Pt. 45) 802
Why it was identified: Ajao is cited as authority on the requirements for a competent court and the nullity resulting from lack of competence.
Other
Attorney-General of Anambra State v. Attorney-General of the Federation
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1993) 6 NWLR (Pt. 302) 692
Why it was identified: The judgment cites this case in stating the factors governing competence and jurisdiction of a court.
Other
Ajilowura v. Disu & 13 Ors.
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2006) All FWLR (Pt. 333) 1613; (2006) 14 NWLR (Pt. 1000) 783
Why it was identified: The judgment discusses Ajilowura in relation to pronouncing the opinion of a deceased Justice under section 294(2) of the 1999 Constitution and distinguishes it from the present case.
Other
Okino v. Obanebira & 4 Ors.
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1998) 12 SCNJ 27
Why it was identified: Okino is expressly cited on the application of the constitutional provision permitting delivery of judgment when not all Justices who heard the appeal are present.
Other
Egba N.A. v. Adeyanju
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1936) 13 NLR 77
Why it was identified: Egba N.A. is identified in the judgment as an earlier authority concerning proceedings conducted by a differently constituted court.
- Court:
- West Africa Court of Appeal
- Citation:
- 3 WACA 230
Why it was identified: Otwiwa is listed and discussed as an authority on the nullity of proceedings where the adjudicating panel changes during the case.
- Court:
- West Africa Court of Appeal
- Citation:
- 12 WACA 167
Why it was identified: Damoah is expressly listed among the earlier cases concerning differently constituted courts and invalid proceedings.
Other
Runka v. Kastina N.A.
AI analysis- Court:
- West Africa Court of Appeal
- Citation:
- (1950) 13 WACA 98
Why it was identified: Runka is identified as an earlier authority on the effect of a court being differently constituted during the hearing.
Other
Mai Rai v. Bauchi N.A.
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1957) NNLR 31
Why it was identified: Mai Rai is cited in argument concerning the invalidity of a judgment delivered by a panel different from the hearing panel.
Other
Queen v. Governor-in-Council (W.R.) Ex parte Laniyan Ojo
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1962) 1 All NLR 147
Why it was identified: This case is cited in the appellants’ argument on the constitutional and procedural invalidity of a judgment delivered by a different panel.
- Court:
- West Africa Court of Appeal
- Citation:
- 9 WACA 181
Why it was identified: Chapman is listed among authorities addressing the effect of a change in the composition of the adjudicating court.
Other
Ashiru Noibi v. R.J. Fikolati
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1987) 1 NWLR (Pt. 52) 619
Why it was identified: The respondent relied on Noibi in arguing that technicalities should not override substantial justice, an argument rejected as inapplicable to the fundamental competence defect.
- Citation:
- (1985) 1 NWLR (Pt. 2) 195
Why it was identified: The respondent relied on Ezomo for the proposition that technicalities should not defeat substantial justice; the Supreme Court distinguished that position from the fundamental defect here.
Other
Tukur v. Government of Taraba State & 2 Ors.
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1997) 6 NWLR (Pt. 510) 549; (1997) 6 SCNJ 81
Why it was identified: Tukur is cited concerning the treatment of an inelegant or defective appellate brief.
Other
Gurara Securities & Finance Ltd v. T. I. C. Ltd
AI analysis- Court:
- Court of Appeal
- Citation:
- (1999) 2 NWLR (Pt. 589) 29
Why it was identified: Gurara Securities is cited on the appellate courts’ treatment of an inelegant brief.
Other
Sofolahan & 5 Ors. v. Chief Folakan & 12 Ors.
AI analysis- Court:
- Court of Appeal
- Citation:
- (1999) 10 NWLR (Pt. 621) 86
Why it was identified: Sofolahan is cited on the approach to an inelegant brief and the use of such a brief for whatever it is worth.