- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2017) All FWLR (Pt. 906) 1433; LPELR-41915 (SC)
Why it was identified: The lead judgment invokes this decision in criticising the repetition of an issue that had already been authoritatively determined by the Supreme Court.
Related subject matter
Federal Republic of Nigeria v. Okey Nwosu
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2016) 17 NWLR (Pt. 1541) 226; (2017) All FWLR (Pt. 883) 1483
Why it was identified: The judgment repeatedly treats this decision as authoritative on the interaction between sections 251(1), 251(3) and 272 of the 1999 Constitution and on criminal jurisdiction over matters listed in section 251(1).
Related subject matter
Attorney-General, Ondo State v. Attorney-General, Federation
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2002) 9 NWLR (Pt. 772) 222; (2002) FWLR (Pt. 111) 1972
Why it was identified: The judgment identifies this case as a full-panel authority concerning the constitutional allocation of jurisdiction over federal offences and the powers of State High Courts.
Related subject matter
Ontario Oil & Gas (Nig.) Ltd v. Federal Republic of Nigeria
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Suit number:
- SC. 518/2015
- Judgment date:
- 26 January 2018
Why it was identified: The judgment refers to this recent Supreme Court decision as reaffirming, under stare decisis, the constitutional jurisdiction principle applied in the present appeal.
Related subject matter
Ikomi v. State
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1986) 3 NWLR (Pt. 28) 340
Why it was identified: The judgment discusses this authority on no-case submissions and states that section 260(2) of the Lagos ACJL altered its position for Lagos State proceedings.
Related subject matter
Abacha v. State
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2001) 3 NWLR (Pt. 699) 35
Why it was identified: The case is cited repeatedly for the distinction between a prima facie case and proof beyond reasonable doubt and for the proper scope of a no-case submission.
Related subject matter
Ohwovoriole v. Federal Republic of Nigeria
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2003) 2 NWLR (Pt. 803) 176; (2003) LPELR-392
Why it was identified: The judgment relies on this case for the definition of a prima facie case and the rule that a no-case submission does not involve evaluating evidence or witness credibility.
Related subject matter
Ekwunugo v. Federal Republic of Nigeria
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2008) 15 NWLR (Pt. 111) 630; (2008) 7 SC 196; (2009) All FWLR (Pt. 450) 614
Why it was identified: Cited as authority on the court's limited duty when considering whether the prosecution has established a prima facie case.
Related subject matter
Tongo v. C.O.P.
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2007) 12 NWLR (Pt. 1049) 525; (2007) All FWLR (Pt. 376) 636; LPELR-SC.105
Why it was identified: Cited for principles governing prima facie evidence and the proper treatment of a no-case submission.
Related subject matter
Daboh v. State
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1977) 5 SC 197; (1977) All NLR 146; LPELR-904
Why it was identified: The judgment cites this case for the rule that the court should not evaluate evidence or assess witness credibility at the no-case stage.
Related subject matter
R. v. Ogucha
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1959) 4 FSC 64
Why it was identified: Cited for the proper stage and scope of a no-case submission and the court's inability to determine whether evidence will sustain a conviction at that stage.
Related subject matter
Ekpo v. State
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2001) 7 NWLR (Pt. 712) 299; (2001) FWLR (Pt. 55) 454
Why it was identified: Cited on the limits of judicial evaluation during a no-case submission and the timing of objections to the sufficiency of evidence.
Related subject matter
Odido v. State
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1995) 1 NWLR (Pt. 369) 88
Why it was identified: Cited for the principle that a trial court should not assess the credibility or weight of evidence while deciding a no-case submission.
Related subject matter
Ubanatu v. C.O.P.
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1997) 7 NWLR (Pt. 616) 512; (2000) FWLR (Pt. 1) 138
Why it was identified: Cited for the rule that the court need only determine whether a prima facie link to the alleged offence has been established at the no-case stage.
Related subject matter
Ajiboye v. State
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1994) 8 NWLR (Pt. 364) 587
Why it was identified: Cited for the meaning of a prima facie case and the appropriate approach to no-case submissions.
Related subject matter
State v. Emedo
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2001) 12 NWLR (Pt. 726) 131
Why it was identified: Cited as authority against evaluating evidence and witness credibility when determining a no-case submission.
Related subject matter
Ajidagba v. I.G.P.
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1958) 3 FSC 5; (1958) SCNLR 60
Why it was identified: The judgment relies on this case as the Nigerian adoption of the definition of prima facie case from the Indian decision in Sher Singy v. Jittendranathsen.
Related subject matter
Sher Singy v. Jittendranathsen
AI analysis- Citation:
- I.L.R. 59 Calc 275
Why it was identified: Identified as the foreign authority from which the definition of prima facie case was adopted in Ajidagba v. I.G.P., a principle applied in the present appeal.
Related subject matter
R-Benkay (Nig.) Ltd v. Cardbury (Nig.) Ltd
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2012) 3 SC (Pt. III) 169; (2012) All FWLR (Pt. 631) 1450; LPELR-7820 (SC)
Why it was identified: Cited for the definition of abuse of court process and relied upon in characterising the present interlocutory appeal as frivolous and vexatious.
Related subject matter
Saraki v. Kotoye
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1992) 9 NWLR (Pt. 264) 156; (1992) 3 NSCC 331; LPELR-3016 (SC)
Why it was identified: Cited for the principle that using judicial process to irritate or annoy an opponent and impair the administration of justice constitutes abuse of process.
Related subject matter
Oke v. Oke
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1974) 3 SC 1; (1974) 1 All NLR (Pt. 1) 443
Why it was identified: Cited in the appellant's submissions concerning the construction of constitutional jurisdiction provisions and the meaning of exclusive jurisdiction.
Related subject matter
L.S.D.P.C. v. Foreign Finance Corporation Ltd
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1987) 1 NWLR (Pt. 50) 413
Why it was identified: Cited in argument on the relationship between sections 251 and 272 of the Constitution and the scope of exclusive jurisdiction.
Related subject matter
Aqua Ltd v. Ondo State Sports Council
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1988) 4 NWLR (Pt. 91) 622; (1988) 10-11 SC 31; (1988) 10-11 SCNJ 26
Why it was identified: Cited in the appellant's submissions on the interpretation of exclusive jurisdiction under the Constitution.
Related subject matter
Idehen v. Idehen
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1991) 6 NWLR (Pt. 198) 382; (1991) SCNJ 196
Why it was identified: Cited in argument concerning the construction of the constitutional jurisdiction provisions.
Related subject matter
Labiyi v. Anretiola
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1992) 8 NWLR (Pt. 258) 139; (1992) 10 SCNJ 1
Why it was identified: Cited in the appellant's jurisdictional submissions concerning section 251 of the Constitution.
Related subject matter
F.R.N. v. Ibori
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2014) 13 NWLR (Pt. 1423) 168
Why it was identified: Cited by the appellant in support of the contention that offences connected with section 251 matters fall within Federal High Court jurisdiction.
Related subject matter
Araka v. Egbue
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2003) 17 NWLR (Pt. 848) 1; (2003) FWLR (Pt. 175) 507; (2003) 9 MJSC 17
Why it was identified: Cited in the appellant's argument concerning concurrent jurisdiction between the Federal High Court and State High Courts.
Related subject matter
N.N.P.C. v. Orhiowosele
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2013) NWLR (Pt. 1371) 211; LPELR-20341
Why it was identified: Cited in support of the appellant's contention that the Federal High Court had exclusive jurisdiction over the charged subject matter.
Related subject matter
Queen v. Owoh
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1962) 1 All NLR 653; (1962) NSCC 416
Why it was identified: Cited by the respondent concerning the extent of the Federal High Court's criminal jurisdiction.
Related subject matter
The State v. Williams
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1978) NSCC 38
Why it was identified: Cited by the respondent on the constitutional allocation of criminal jurisdiction.
Related subject matter
Akwule v. The Queen
AI analysis- Citation:
- (1963) 1 SCNLR 385; (1963) NSCC 157
Why it was identified: Cited by the respondent concerning criminal jurisdiction and the Federal High Court.
Related subject matter
Eze v. Federal Republic of Nigeria
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1987) 1 NWLR (Pt. 51) 506; (1987) 1 NSCC 249; (1987) 2 SCNJ 53
Why it was identified: Cited in the appellant's reply on the constitutional interpretation advanced in relation to section 251.
Related subject matter
Mandara v. Attorney-General, Federation
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (1984) 4 SC 8; (1984) All NLR 219; (1984) NSCC 221; (1984) 1 SCNLR 311
Why it was identified: Cited in the appellant's reply concerning the effect of constitutional wording on jurisdiction.
Related subject matter
Garba v. Mohammed
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- LPELR-4061 (SC); (2017) All FWLR (Pt. 867) 420
Why it was identified: Cited in the appellant's reply for the interpretive significance of the word 'notwithstanding' in the Constitution.
Related subject matter
Abacha v. State
AI analysis- Court:
- Supreme Court of Nigeria
- Citation:
- (2002) 11 NWLR (Pt. 779) 437; (2002) FWLR (Pt. 118) 1224; (2002) 9 MJSC 1
Why it was identified: Cited for principles concerning no-case submissions and whether proof of evidence discloses an offence or a prima facie case.